🔗 Share this article

During the 10th of September, 1943, an informal circle of well-connected friends met in a modest flat in Charlottenberg district. Their hostess was Elisabeth von Thadden, and the stated purpose for the meeting was her sister’s fiftieth birthday. However, it served as a pretext for several key individuals meeting to discuss what should happen now that it was clear that Germany was losing World War II.

Courage and Conviction

Kiep, one-time consul, talked hopefully about how Mussolini’s recent toppling indicated Italy’s willingness to make peace with the Allied forces. Simultaneously, political hostess Hanna Solf excitedly imagined Hitler’s downfall: “We’ll put him against a wall.” The hostess, a devout Protestant and ex-principal of a prestigious academy, highlighted the human suffering that was sure to follow peace was achieved. For those who gathered on that late summer’s day for tea, sandwiches and a particularly unappetising food item referred to as “ration cake,” the country’s transformation into a republic appeared imminent that it felt tangible.

The Shift in Loyalty

Few among them were natural rebels. Many were from prominent army lineages who had been burned by the outcome of the Great War and the ensuing disgrace of the treaty of Versailles. To these quintessential patriots, the Nazis’ pledge to rebuild the nation’s honor, not to mention prosperity, had been initially appealing. The restoration to the enduring values of cultural icons was expected to follow.

That idealism soon faded. When the grim reality of their policies for ethnic purification emerged, no one could to stand by. Back in 1933, Otto Kiep, at the time a diplomat to the US, risked everything to publicly honour the famous physicist, the best-known Jewish refugee opposed to Hitler. It earned him an immediate recall back home. As for the hostess, her awakening occurred when she saw the regime’s plan envisioned for faith – a state-controlled religion in which the Führer superseded Jesus Christ. For Countess Lagi von Ballestrem, the mission was helping hundreds of “submarines” – Jews in hiding – make it through freezing months, and directing them toward safety via a network of tunnels and forged documents. Lagi excelled at subtle defiance: in all her movements, she took care to grip parcels of bulky washing in each hand – it allowed her for omitting the mandated salute.

Betrayal and Consequences

What no one realised before the damage was done was that a betrayer had infiltrated in their midst. This individual came at the tea party seemingly trustworthy, but looking back, there was something fishy regarding this person. He hung on to each conversation like he was memorizing details and sought to extract revelations about additional plans. The reason was he documented everything and submitting it to his Gestapo boss, the infamously brutal Herbert Lange. Soon after, the majority who had attended the gathering would be killed or incarcerated.

Twists of Fate

Across numerous concise sections, every conclusion leaving suspense, the book follows the twists and turns by which these reluctant heroes tried to escape and ultimately confront their outcomes. Initially an eerie quiet followed, then arrived an official visit or a tap on the shoulder. Given that these were high-profile detainees with names or fortunes linked to the country’s old guard, there was no doubt that they would be exploited in publicity stunts. Public trials were held, including renowned attorneys and relatives begging for mercy. It didn’t do any good. Kiep faced execution by hanging, Von Thadden lost her head. Another member, a senior bureaucrat at the German ministry of finance, briefly got free from his guards and leap to his demise, those remaining were condemned to years behind bars.

A Thrilling yet Thought-Provoking Work

This book represents that elusive thing – a fact-based narrative that progresses as dynamically as an airport thriller. Yet this is also a profoundly serious work, raising a challenging query: How many of us could muster the strength to act defiantly, protest openly and confront the grim outcomes?